Potions: A Curious Tale

Potions: A Curious Tale is an enchanting action-adventure game set in a whimsical fantasy world where you play as Luna, a young witch-in-training. The game immerses you in the art of potion-making, allowing you to experiment with various ingredients and concoctions to solve puzzles and progress through the story. As you journey through a beautifully crafted fairy tale landscape, you’ll uncover side quests and challenges that test your creativity and problem-solving skills, making it a delightful experience for cozy gamers and puzzle enthusiasts alike.

Potions: A Curious Tale: A Wistful Brew of Charm and Ambition

A decade in the making, Stumbling Cat’s debut title invites players into a cozy yet uneven fairy tale.

---

Introduction

In an industry dominated by hyper-violent power fantasies and sprawling open worlds, Potions: A Curious Tale dares to ask: What if the hero’s greatest weapon wasn’t a sword, but creativity? Developed by Seattle-based indie studio Stumbling Cat and led by veteran developer Renee Gittins, this 2024 adventure RPG blends whimsical storytelling, environmental puzzle-solving, and a surprisingly deep potion-crafting system. While its seams occasionally show—uneven pacing, cluttered UI—the game carves a niche as a heartfelt ode to wit over violence, fairy tale nostalgia, and the quiet resilience of indie development.

---

Development History & Context

A Labor of Love (and Struggle)

Potions: A Curious Tale began as a Kickstarter project in 2014, raising $65,000 fueled by Gittins’ vision of a game that rejected “needless violence” and centered a young witch’s ingenuity. The decade-long journey was fraught with challenges: team member Jason Lentz’s tragic passing during development, Gittins’ burnout, and a disastrous launch day overshadowed by EA’s surprise re-release of classics like Command & Conquer on Steam.

A Crowded Cozy Landscape

The game arrived amidst a boom in cozy, narrative-driven titles like Stardew Valley and Wytchwood. Gittins intentionally targeted International Women’s Day 2024 for release, positioning Luna’s story as an empowerment allegory. However, the indie market’s saturation and the game’s niche mechanics left it struggling for visibility until Gittins’ viral TikTok about its rocky launch drew mainstream attention.

Technical Constraints

Built in Unity with Wwise for sound, Potions leans into simplicity. Its 2.5D art style—2D characters in 3D diorama-like environments—allowed the small team to focus on charm over graphical prowess. Yet, the lack of a map system and clunky fast travel (even post-launch patches only partially addressed these) reflect the studio’s limited resources.

---

Narrative & Thematic Deep Dive

A Witch’s Coming-of-Age

Players step into the shoes of Luna, a 12-year-old witch apprentice sent to her grandmother’s village, Old Haven. The plot is a gentle tapestry of self-discovery, weaving mythic figures like Sinbad and Rumpelstiltskin into Luna’s journey to master potion-making and confront a “rising darkness.” While the writing is earnest, critics noted underdeveloped arcs—villains lack depth, and pivotal moments like a kraken battle end abruptly.

Themes: Subtlety Over Spectacle

• Empathy as Power: Combat is discouraged; players bait enemies into environmental traps (e.g., luring rats into fire). This mirrors Gittins’ philosophy: “Respect is earned, adults aren’t always right.”
• Folklore as Foundation: The world teems with fairy tale allusions, though their integration feels more decorative than transformative.
• Female Agency: Luna’s growth—from timid student to confident witch—resonates, particularly in scenes where young players at conventions exclaimed, “That’s me!”

---

Gameplay Mechanics & Systems

Potion Crafting: The Heart of the Experience

The core loop revolves around gathering ingredients (mushrooms, feathers, ash) and experimenting with over 100 recipes. Ingredients possess elemental “mana” (fire, water, etc.), and combining three unlocks effects like explosions or healing. While recipes can be discovered organically, the game often handholds players with quest-specific hints—a missed opportunity for deeper experimentation.

Combat (or Lack Thereof)

Luna avoids traditional combat, instead using potions to manipulate environments. For example, freezing water to create platforms or tricking a kraken into smashing itself. Critics praised this originality but lamented repetitive enemy behaviors and limited boss strategies.

UI and Progression Woes

• Cluttered Quest Log: Objectives pile up on-screen, obscuring visibility (Movies Games and Tech called it an “eyesore”).
• No Map System: Exploration becomes tedious, reliant on memorizing biomes like the “Deep Dark Forest.”
• Broom Flight: Unlocked early, the broom alleviates traversal but highlights the empty overworld.

---

World-Building, Art & Sound

Visual Style: Ghibli Meets Indie Charm

The art direction blends Studio Ghibli-inspired painterly backdrops with cel-shaded characters, creating a storybook aesthetic. However, inconsistency plagues the design: NPC portraits pop with personality (Helios the cat is a standout), while enemies and environments feel underdone.

Sound Design: A Mixed Elixir

Sunglae Park’s folksy soundtrack leans into cozy vibes but struggles to elevate key moments. Footsteps and potion-brewing SFX are satisfying, though repetitive. The lack of voice acting outside D.B. Cooper’s brief cameo leaves dialogue feeling static.

---

Reception & Legacy

Critical Divide

Potions earned a 70% average from critics (via MobyGames) and an 89% “Very Positive” Steam rating. Praise centered on its relaxing pace and inventive crafting (KeenGamer: “hours of experimentation”). Criticisms targeted pacing, shallow NPCs, and a rushed finale (RPGamer: “a mixed bag”).

Commercial Impact

Despite a rocky launch, the game found an audience among cozy gamers and parents seeking non-violent options. Its Steam success (326 reviews at launch) led to console ports in late 2025, bundled with free DLC (a post-game temple).

Industry Influence

While not revolutionary, Potions demonstrated indie resilience. Gittins’ transparency about development struggles inspired aspiring creators, and its empathy-driven design paved the way for titles like Echoes of Wisdom.

---

Conclusion

Potions: A Curious Tale is a flawed but heartfelt experiment. Its potion-crafting shines, and Luna’s journey—while uneven—carries a quiet sincerity. For cozy gamers craving whimsy, it’s worth brewing a cup of tea and diving in. For others, the lack of polish may dilute the magic. Yet, as a testament to indie perseverance and feminist game design, it deserves a place in the annals of cult classics.

Final Verdict: 7/10 – A charming, if imperfect, ode to creativity and quiet courage.