The Nightmare Cooperative

The Nightmare Cooperative is a turn‑based, roguelike dungeon crawler set in a fantasy world where a party of diverse characters—fighters, priests, miners, and astral walkers—must move and act in unison as they explore procedurally generated levels across four perilous realms, facing permadeath and strategic challenges.

The Nightmare Cooperative: Review

Introduction

When Lucky Frame Ltd. unveiled The Nightmare Cooperative on July 16 2014, it arrived at a moment when the indie roguelike renaissance was in full swing. The game’s premise—lead a rag‑tag troupe of adventurers through a procedurally generated dungeon while moving every member in lock‑step—felt both oddly familiar and startlingly fresh. Its modest $4.99 price tag and “fiendishly difficult” reputation promised a bite‑sized yet brutal experience. My thesis is simple: The Nightmare Cooperative is a masterclass in minimalist design that leverages a unique cooperative control scheme to deliver a strategic puzzle‑roguelike, though its shortcomings in polish and depth keep it from attaining classic status.

---

Development History & Context

The Studio and Vision

Lucky Frame Ltd., a tiny UK‑based indie studio founded by Jonathan “Jonbro” Brodsky, birthed the game as a 7‑day prototype for the 7DRL (7‑Day Roguelike) competition. The prototype, built in Unity3D, emphasized “small puzzle roguelikes” and drew direct inspiration from titles such as Zaga‑33 and 868‑HACK. The rapid development cycle forced the designers to strip the genre down to its essentials: turn‑based movement, procedural levels, permadeath, and a single, unifying mechanic—collective control.

Technological Constraints

Running on a fixed, diagonal‑down perspective with flip‑screen tiles, the game required only 1 GB RAM and a modest 200 MB of storage on its minimum Windows, macOS, and Linux builds. The lightweight Unity engine allowed the developers to ship a cross‑platform title (Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android) without sacrificing performance on low‑end hardware.

Gaming Landscape

In 2014, the indie market was hungry for fresh takes on classic roguelikes. Desktop Dungeons, FTL: Faster Than Light, and Michael Brough’s 868‑HACK had proven that tight, turn‑based systems could thrive on mobile and PC alike. The Nightmare Cooperative entered this arena with a twist: instead of a single hero, you commanded an entire party as a single unit, a concept that set it apart from contemporaries and foreshadowed later “co‑op” roguelikes such as Spaceland: Cooperative (2021) and Black Hat Cooperative (2016).

---

Narrative & Thematic Deep Dive

Plot Overview

The story is deliberately spare. A beleaguered village, crippled by reckless spending from its council, sends its last hope—the Cooperative—into a nightmarish dungeon to amass gold. The player’s objective is two‑fold: survive long enough to loot treasure and return with enough gold to keep the village afloat.

Characters & Dialogue

The party consists of archetypal fantasy roles, each with a flamboyant back‑story and a dry, sardonic voice:

• Warrior – “Fights hard despite her moral objections.”
• Miner – “Overcomes deep psychological issues to dig you out of sticky situations.”
• Necromancer – “Pretty creepy.”
• Archer, Mage, Ninja, and others (mentioned in community discussions) each have quirks that surface in brief, humor‑laden tooltip text.

The narrative’s humor leans heavily on bureaucratic absurdity (“life insurance policies are null and void upon signup”) and meta‑commentary about death in a roguelike (“not everyone who fails to come back is technically dead”). This tone softens the relentless difficulty, making each death feel like a punchline rather than a punishment.

Underlying Themes

• Cooperation vs. Individualism – The forced synchrony of movement forces players to think as a collective, echoing the game’s title and the village’s reliance on shared effort.
• Resource Scarcity – Gold is both a score and a lifeline for the village, underscoring the desperation driving the adventure.
• Bureaucratic Negligence – The council’s overspending is a tongue‑in‑cheek critique of mismanagement, framing the dungeon crawl as a civic duty.

---

Gameplay Mechanics & Systems

Core Loop

1. Enter a procedurally generated level (four worlds total).
2. Move the entire party with a single set of keys (e.g., arrow keys or WASD).
3. Activate a class‑specific ability (all members act simultaneously).
4. Encounter enemies that react to your movement; each step is a tactical decision.
5. Collect gold from chests and defeated foes; opening chests spawns additional monsters.
6. Reach the exit or perish (permadeath).

The loop repeats until the player either escapes with a respectable gold haul or is wiped out.

Control Scheme & UI

• Keyboard + Mouse (optional).
• Diagonal‑down, fixed‑screen tiles reminiscent of classic SSI Gold Box RPGs.
• Single‑player only (the “co‑op” refers to party cooperation, not multiplayer).

Community feedback highlights occasional frustration with the “all‑move‑together” mechanic, especially when a single character’s position forces the whole group into danger.

Character Classes & Abilities

Class	Signature Ability	Tactical Role
Warrior	Double strike per turn	Front‑line damage, clears straight lines
Miner	Dig (remove obstacles)	Access hidden tiles, rescue trapped allies
Necromancer	Summon/curse (creepy)	Crowd control, indirect damage
Archer	Forward shot	Long‑range linear attacks
Mage	Diagonal blast	Hits enemies out of straight line
Ninja	Phase through enemies	Bypass blockers, reposition
… (others)	Various situational powers	Complementary support

Each ability is global: when you press the class button, every member performs that action, making positioning crucial.

Enemy Design

Enemies exhibit predictable patterns (linear patrols, mirroring player movement, rotating turrets). Some move extra squares per turn, forcing the player to anticipate multi‑step consequences. The “enemy‑move‑on‑player‑move” rule turns every step into a puzzle, reminiscent of 868‑HACK’s “move‑and‑shoot” rhythm.

Progression & Items

• Gold is the sole long‑term resource and the final score.
• Items (e.g., extra life at the cost of mana, chest‑spawn modifiers) appear as temporary buffs.
• No deep skill trees or equipment systems; the game deliberately avoids “loot‑crunch” to keep the focus on strategic positioning.

Innovations & Flaws

Innovations
– Simultaneous party control creates a fresh tactical layer rarely seen in roguelikes.
– Minimalist UI forces players to rely on mental maps and foresight.

Flaws
– The control scheme can feel clunky, especially on keyboards without arrow keys.
– Lack of character progression may leave hardcore roguelike fans wanting more depth.
– Early builds suffered from occasional crashes on macOS Retina displays (reported on Steam forums).

---

World‑Building, Art & Sound

Setting & Atmosphere

The dungeon is a fantasy nightmare broken into four distinct worlds, each with its own visual palette and monster roster. The setting is deliberately abstract; the focus stays on the puzzle‑like combat rather than narrative exposition.

Visual Direction

• Pixel‑ish, 8‑bit‑inspired art that evokes classic Gold Box titles.
• Bright, saturated colors help differentiate hero classes and enemy types.
• Fixed flip‑screen makes each room feel like a self‑contained puzzle board.

Audio Design

Full‑audio implementation (both music and sound effects) is present, though specific tracks are not documented in the source material. The soundscape leans toward retro chiptune and ambient dungeon ambience, reinforcing the gritty, high‑stakes mood.

Contribution to Experience

The cohesive visual‑audio style, combined with the relentless turn‑based tension, creates a tight feedback loop: each move is audible, each enemy’s turn is accompanied by a subtle cue, and the player’s mind is forced into a state of methodical calculation—exactly what a roguelike should feel like.

---

Reception & Legacy

Critical Reception

Platform	Metacritic Score	Notable Reviews
iOS (iPhone/iPad)	83 (Generally Favorable)	Pocket Gamer UK (90/100), 148Apps (80/100), TouchArcade (80/100), Apple’N’Apps (80/100)
Windows (Steam)	Mixed (Player Score 50/100)	66 positive / 66 negative out of 132 user reviews (Steambase)

Critical consensus praised the game’s tight design, clever mechanics, and humor, especially on mobile where the “slide‑based” implementation felt natural.

Commercial Performance

• Price: $4.99 on Steam (originally $5.99 on some storefronts).
• Sales Data: Not disclosed, but modest “collected by 36 players” on MobyGames suggests a niche but dedicated audience.

Community & Post‑Launch Support

• Developer Interaction: Frequent Steam community posts by Jonbro answered bugs, announced a challenge mode, and discussed mobile ports.
• Patches: Updated for macOS 10.14+ and 32‑bit deprecation (2024).
• Ports: Released on iPhone, iPad, Android, Linux, and macOS, expanding its reach beyond PC.

Influence

The Nightmare Cooperative helped solidify the “co‑op roguelike” sub‑genre and inspired later titles such as Spaceland: Cooperative (2021) and Black Hat Cooperative (2016). Its emphasis on simultaneous party movement is often cited in indie design retrospectives as a clever solution to the “single‑hero” constraint.

Legacy Assessment

While never a mainstream hit, the game enjoys a cult status among roguelike purists who appreciate its puzzle‑centric design. Its Metacritic 83 on iOS demonstrates that, when the control scheme aligns with platform expectations, the experience shines. On PC, the mixed reception reflects the friction caused by the same control scheme on a keyboard‑centric audience.

---

Conclusion

The Nightmare Cooperative is a compact, brilliantly engineered puzzle‑roguelike that succeeds through restraint. Its core innovation—moving an entire party as one—creates a fresh strategic layer that rewards careful planning and quick adaptation. The game’s humor, minimalist art, and tight turn‑based combat make each run feel like a short, intense brain‑teaser.

However, the single‑control scheme can become a double‑edged sword, especially on platforms where precision input is limited, and the lack of deeper character progression may leave veterans yearning for more.

Verdict: The Nightmare Cooperative deserves a solid place in the annals of indie roguelikes—a title that, while not a genre‑defining masterpiece, exemplifies how a modest budget and a bold design choice can produce a memorable, challenging experience. For fans of turn‑based strategy and puzzle‑driven dungeon crawls, it remains a must‑play curiosity that continues to inspire cooperative mechanics in newer indie titles.