Age of Empires II: HD Edition

Age of Empires II: HD Edition is an enhanced remake of the classic real-time strategy game, Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings, and its expansion, The Conquerors. Set in the medieval period, players lead civilizations through historical events across Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and the Americas, building empires, managing resources, and engaging in tactical warfare. The HD Edition features high-resolution graphics, multi-monitor support, improved compatibility with modern operating systems, and Steam Workshop integration for custom content and multiplayer battles.

Age of Empires II: HD Edition: A Timeless Masterpiece Revisited

Introduction

In the pantheon of real-time strategy (RTS) games, few titles have achieved the legendary status of Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings. Released in 1999 by Ensemble Studios, this medieval-themed RTS became an instant classic, captivating millions with its deep gameplay, historical campaigns, and competitive multiplayer. Over a decade later, Age of Empires II: HD Edition (2013) emerged as a remastered tribute to this beloved game, bringing it to modern audiences with enhanced visuals, improved multiplayer, and Steam Workshop support. This review explores the HD Edition’s development, gameplay, reception, and enduring legacy, arguing that while it may not have revolutionized the original, it successfully preserved and revitalized a timeless classic for a new generation.

---

Development History & Context

The Legacy of the Original

Age of Empires II: The Age of Kings was developed by Ensemble Studios and published by Microsoft in 1999. Building on the success of its predecessor, Age of Empires (1997), the game refined the RTS formula with a focus on medieval warfare, resource management, and historical campaigns. The original game featured 13 civilizations, five single-player campaigns, and a robust multiplayer mode that supported up to eight players. Its success was immediate, with over two million copies sold within three months of release and critical acclaim for its depth, balance, and historical authenticity.

The Need for a Remaster

By the early 2010s, Age of Empires II was showing its age. The game’s resolution was locked to 1024×768, and its multiplayer relied on outdated services like the MSN Gaming Zone, which had shut down in 2006. Fans had kept the game alive through community patches and third-party multiplayer clients like GameRanger, but the lack of official support and modern conveniences made it increasingly difficult for new players to experience the game as intended.

Enter Age of Empires II: HD Edition, developed by Hidden Path Entertainment and released on April 9, 2013. The project was spearheaded by Matt Pritchard, a former lead programmer at Ensemble Studios, who sought to bring the game to modern platforms with enhanced visuals and improved multiplayer functionality. The HD Edition was not a complete overhaul but rather a careful remastering that preserved the core gameplay while adding quality-of-life improvements.

Key Enhancements

1. Visual Upgrades: The HD Edition introduced support for higher resolutions, improved textures, and widescreen compatibility. While the game’s sprite-based graphics remained largely unchanged, the update allowed it to run smoothly on modern displays.
2. Steam Integration: The move to Steam brought several benefits, including Steam Workshop support for user-generated content, Steam Trading Cards, and a modern multiplayer infrastructure with matchmaking and leaderboards.
3. Gameplay Improvements: The population limit was increased from 200 to 500, allowing for larger battles. The AI received an overhaul, and balance changes were implemented to refine the competitive experience.
4. Expansion Support: The HD Edition included the original game and The Conquerors expansion, with plans for additional expansions like The Forgotten (2013), The African Kingdoms (2015), and Rise of the Rajas (2016).

Development Challenges

Despite its successes, the HD Edition faced criticism for its limited scope. Many fans had hoped for more substantial visual upgrades, such as 3D models or redesigned interfaces. However, the development team prioritized preserving the original gameplay experience, fearing that drastic changes might alienate the game’s dedicated fanbase. This conservative approach led to mixed reactions, with some praising the faithful remastering and others lamenting the missed opportunities for innovation.

---

Narrative & Thematic Deep Dive

Historical Campaigns

Age of Empires II: HD Edition retained the original game’s five historically based campaigns, each centered around a different civilization and historical figure:

1. William Wallace (Celts): A tutorial campaign set during the Wars of Scottish Independence, teaching players the basics of resource gathering, unit training, and combat.
2. Joan of Arc (Franks): A dramatic retelling of Joan of Arc’s role in the Hundred Years’ War, featuring iconic battles like the Siege of Orleans.
3. Saladin (Saracens): Focuses on Saladin’s defense of the Holy Land against the Crusaders, culminating in the Battle of Hattin.
4. Genghis Khan (Mongols): Documents the rise of the Mongol Empire, from Genghis Khan’s early struggles to his conquest of Eurasia.
5. Frederick Barbarossa (Teutons): Follows the Holy Roman Emperor’s campaigns in Europe, including his conflicts with the Lombard League.

These campaigns were praised for their historical authenticity and engaging storytelling, though they took creative liberties for gameplay purposes. The HD Edition did not alter the campaigns but preserved them as a testament to the game’s narrative strengths.

Themes of Empire and Conflict

At its core, Age of Empires II explores themes of empire-building, cultural identity, and the cyclical nature of conflict. The game’s progression through the Dark Age, Feudal Age, Castle Age, and Imperial Age mirrors the historical development of medieval societies, from humble beginnings to the heights of power. Each civilization’s unique units, technologies, and architectural styles reflect their historical counterparts, adding depth to the gameplay and reinforcing the game’s educational value.

The game also highlights the interconnectedness of medieval cultures. Trade routes, diplomatic alliances, and military conflicts are central to the gameplay, emphasizing the complex relationships between civilizations. Whether through the Crusades, the Mongol invasions, or the Wars of Scottish Independence, Age of Empires II presents history as a dynamic and often brutal struggle for dominance.

Dialogue and Localization

One of the original game’s most charming features was its use of native language sound bites for each civilization. Villagers and units would speak in their respective languages when selected or given orders, adding immersion and authenticity. The HD Edition preserved this feature, ensuring that the game’s audio design remained a highlight. However, some critics noted that the voice acting in the campaigns could be uneven, with accents and delivery occasionally feeling inauthentic.

---

Gameplay Mechanics & Systems

Core Gameplay Loop

Age of Empires II: HD Edition retains the classic RTS gameplay loop of resource gathering, base building, and military conquest. Players begin in the Dark Age with a Town Center, a few villagers, and a scout unit. From there, they must gather food, wood, gold, and stone to advance through the ages, unlocking new units, buildings, and technologies.

1. Resource Management: Villagers are the backbone of the economy, gathering resources from farms, forests, mines, and fishing spots. Efficient resource management is crucial, as shortages can cripple a player’s ability to produce units or advance to the next age.
2. Base Building: Players must construct a variety of buildings, from economic structures like mills and markets to military buildings like barracks and stables. Defensive structures like walls and towers are also essential for protecting against enemy raids.
3. Unit Production and Combat: The game features a rock-paper-scissors combat system, where different unit types counter others. For example, spearmen are effective against cavalry, while archers excel against infantry. Mastering unit counters and formations is key to military success.
4. Technology Research: Advancing through the ages and researching technologies at buildings like the blacksmith or university can provide significant advantages, such as improved armor, faster production, or stronger units.

Multiplayer and Competitive Play

The HD Edition’s most significant improvement was its modernized multiplayer infrastructure. The move to Steam allowed for seamless matchmaking, ranked lobbies, and leaderboards, making it easier than ever for players to find opponents and track their progress. The game supports up to eight players in a variety of modes, including:

1. Random Map: The most popular mode, where players start on a randomly generated map with limited resources and must compete for dominance.
2. Deathmatch: Players begin with abundant resources, leading to fast-paced, high-intensity battles.
3. Regicide: Each player controls a king unit, and the goal is to eliminate the opposing kings.
4. Capture the Relic: A mode introduced in later expansions, where players compete to control relics scattered across the map.

The HD Edition also introduced Steam Workshop support, allowing players to create and share custom maps, scenarios, and mods. This feature greatly extended the game’s replayability and fostered a vibrant modding community.

AI and Balance

The HD Edition included an overhauled AI system designed to provide a more challenging and realistic opponent. The AI no longer “cheated” by giving itself extra resources but instead relied on improved decision-making and strategic planning. Balance changes were also implemented to address long-standing issues, such as the dominance of certain civilizations or units in competitive play.

However, the AI was not without its flaws. Pathfinding issues, where units would take inefficient routes or get stuck, remained a persistent problem. Additionally, the AI’s difficulty scaling could feel inconsistent, with lower difficulty settings being too easy and higher settings relying on overwhelming numbers rather than tactical brilliance.

Quality-of-Life Improvements

While the HD Edition did not drastically alter the core gameplay, it introduced several quality-of-life improvements that enhanced the overall experience:

1. Increased Population Limit: The population cap was raised from 200 to 500, allowing for larger armies and more epic battles.
2. Improved UI: The user interface was updated to support higher resolutions and widescreen displays, though some critics felt it could have been more modernized.
3. New Game Modes: Expansions like The Forgotten introduced new modes like Treaty, where players agree to a period of peace before all-out war, and Capture the Relic.
4. Spectator Mode: Added in later updates, this feature allowed players to watch matches in real-time, fostering a growing esports scene.

---

World-Building, Art & Sound

Visual Design

The HD Edition’s visual upgrades were modest but effective. The game’s sprite-based graphics were upscaled to support higher resolutions, and textures were improved to look sharper on modern displays. While the art style remained largely unchanged, the update ensured that the game could be enjoyed on contemporary hardware without sacrificing its classic aesthetic.

One of the most notable visual improvements was the enhanced fog of war, which added a sense of mystery and tension to exploration. The game’s unit and building designs were also refined, with more detailed animations and effects. However, some critics argued that the visual upgrades were too subtle, leaving the game feeling dated compared to more modern RTS titles.

Sound Design and Music

The sound design in Age of Empires II: HD Edition is a standout feature, with a rich and immersive audio experience. The game’s soundtrack, composed by Stephen Rippy, blends medieval-inspired melodies with ethnic instruments to create a sense of time and place. Each civilization has its own unique musical themes, further enhancing the game’s cultural authenticity.

The ambient sounds, from the clanging of blacksmiths to the bustling of markets, add depth to the gameplay experience. Combat sounds are equally impressive, with the clash of swords, the twang of bowstrings, and the thunder of siege engines creating a dynamic and engaging battlefield atmosphere.

Atmosphere and Immersion

The combination of visual and audio design in Age of Empires II: HD Edition creates a deeply immersive atmosphere. The game’s attention to historical detail, from the architecture of buildings to the design of units, transports players to the medieval world. The campaigns, with their dramatic storytelling and historical settings, further enhance this sense of immersion, making players feel like they are part of a living, breathing history.

---

Reception & Legacy

Critical Reception

Age of Empires II: HD Edition received generally positive reviews, with critics praising its faithful remastering of the original game and its modern multiplayer features. On Metacritic, the game holds a score of 68/100 based on 20 critic reviews, indicating “mixed or average” reception. While some reviewers appreciated the game’s nostalgia and improved accessibility, others criticized its lack of innovation and persistent technical issues.

1. Positive Reviews:

   • Gamer.no (90%): Praised the game as a “solid package” that would satisfy even the most hardcore strategy fans, highlighting its eight campaigns, robust multiplayer, and extensive modding support.
   • Cheat Code Central (88%): Called the HD Edition a “glorious palette of pixel art” and a nostalgic trip for fans of the original.
   • Games Finder (85%): Noted that the gameplay still held up to modern standards and commended the increased unit caps and Steam Workshop integration.

2. Mixed Reviews:

   • GameQuarter (82%): Criticized the lack of significant visual upgrades and UI improvements, arguing that the HD Edition felt too similar to the original.
   • Destructoid (80%): Acknowledged the game’s brilliance but noted that its age could be a barrier for new players.
   • GameStar (Germany) (77%): Praised the core gameplay but expressed disappointment at the lack of substantial changes, calling it a “half-hearted” remake.

3. Negative Reviews:

   • GameSpot (55%): Criticized the game for its numerous bugs and lack of meaningful improvements, arguing that it failed to live up to its potential.
   • Games.cz (40%): Called the HD Edition “strangely outdated” and lacking in originality, suggesting that it appealed neither to newcomers nor to veterans.

Commercial Success

Despite the mixed critical reception, Age of Empires II: HD Edition was a commercial success. The game topped Steam’s sales charts upon release and attracted a large player base, thanks in part to its nostalgic appeal and the growing popularity of esports. The HD Edition’s success paved the way for the Definitive Edition (2019), which further modernized the game with 4K visuals, new civilizations, and additional quality-of-life improvements.

Influence on the Genre

Age of Empires II has had a profound influence on the RTS genre, inspiring numerous games and shaping the design of future titles. Its rock-paper-scissors combat system, resource management mechanics, and historical campaigns have become staples of the genre. Games like Star Wars: Galactic Battlegrounds (2001) and Empire Earth (2001) borrowed heavily from Age of Empires II‘s design, while later titles like Cossacks: European Wars (2001) and Rise of Nations (2003) expanded on its ideas.

The HD Edition’s success also demonstrated the viability of remastering classic games for modern audiences. It proved that there was a market for updated versions of beloved titles, provided they were handled with care and respect for the original experience. This trend has continued with other remasters, such as Age of Mythology: Extended Edition (2014) and Age of Empires: Definitive Edition (2018).

Esports and Community

One of the most significant aspects of Age of Empires II: HD Edition‘s legacy is its impact on the esports scene. The game’s competitive multiplayer, combined with Steam’s matchmaking and spectator features, helped foster a thriving esports community. Tournaments like King of the Desert, Hidden Cup, and Red Bull Wololo have drawn thousands of viewers, with top players like TheViper, Hera, and Daut becoming celebrities in the scene.

The game’s modding community has also played a crucial role in its longevity. The Steam Workshop has allowed players to create and share custom maps, scenarios, and mods, extending the game’s replayability and fostering creativity. Community-driven projects, such as The Forgotten Empires mod, which later became an official expansion, highlight the passion and dedication of Age of Empires II fans.

---

Conclusion

Age of Empires II: HD Edition is a testament to the enduring appeal of a classic game. While it may not have revolutionized the original, it successfully preserved and revitalized Age of Empires II for a new generation of players. The HD Edition’s modernized multiplayer, Steam Workshop support, and quality-of-life improvements ensured that the game remained relevant in an era dominated by more visually advanced titles.

The game’s legacy is undeniable. It has influenced countless RTS titles, inspired a dedicated esports community, and fostered a vibrant modding scene. Its historical campaigns, deep gameplay mechanics, and immersive atmosphere continue to captivate players over two decades after the original’s release.

For fans of the original, the HD Edition is a nostalgic trip down memory lane, offering a chance to relive the glory days of medieval warfare. For newcomers, it is an opportunity to experience one of the greatest RTS games of all time, with all the modern conveniences of Steam integration and multiplayer matchmaking.

In the end, Age of Empires II: HD Edition is more than just a remaster—it is a celebration of a timeless classic. Its place in video game history is secure, and its influence will continue to be felt for years to come. Whether you’re a seasoned veteran or a curious newcomer, Age of Empires II: HD Edition offers an experience that is as rewarding today as it was in 1999.

Final Verdict: 8.5/10 – A faithful and essential remaster of a classic RTS, with modern multiplayer and modding support that ensures its longevity.