Commandos 2: Men of Courage

Commandos 2: Men of Courage is a real-time tactics game set during World War II, where players command an elite squad of Allied operatives on covert missions across Europe and the Pacific. The game features a diverse cast of commandos, each with unique abilities, and offers an expanded interactive environment, allowing players to infiltrate, manipulate, and complete missions using stealth and strategy.

Commandos 2: Men of Courage: Review

Introduction

In the pantheon of real-time tactical games, few titles command as much reverence as Commandos 2: Men of Courage. Released in 2001 by Pyro Studios, this World War II-themed masterpiece redefined the stealth-strategy genre with its punishing complexity, cinematic ambition, and intricate level design. Set against the backdrop of global conflict, the game tasks players with leading an elite squad of Allied operatives through covert missions that span from the Arctic Circle to the jungles of Burma. This review argues that Commandos 2 remains a benchmark for tactical gameplay, blending relentless challenge with unparalleled atmospheric depth—even as its imperfections remind us of the era’s technological limitations.

---

Development History & Context

Studio & Vision:
Developed by Madrid-based Pyro Studios and published by Eidos Interactive, Commandos 2 was crafted with a $7 million budget—a significant investment for its time. Pyro sought to expand upon the success of Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines (1998), doubling down on interactivity, narrative depth, and visual fidelity. The studio’s vision was clear: to create a war epic that fused the tension of stealth with the grandeur of Hollywood-style set pieces.

Technological Constraints:
In an era transitioning to 3D, Commandos 2 retained its isometric perspective but introduced 3D interiors and rotating cameras, a compromise between innovation and the limitations of early-2000s hardware. Pre-rendered cinematics bridged missions, evoking the cinematic flair of WWII films like The Guns of Navarone and Saving Private Ryan. However, technical hiccups—such as abrupt crashes and resolution flickering between menus—betrayed the ambition.

Gaming Landscape:
The game debuted amidst a wave of WWII-themed titles (Medal of Honor, Company of Heroes), but stood apart by prioritizing methodical planning over action. Its arrival coincided with the rise of PC gaming as a hub for complex strategy games, yet its console ports (PlayStation 2, Xbox) struggled to translate its mouse-driven precision to controllers, earning mixed reviews.

---

Narrative & Thematic Deep Dive

Plot & Characters:
Spanning 1941–1945, Commandos 2 follows an ensemble cast of specialists—Green Beret Jack O’Hara, sniper Thomas Hancock, seductive spy Natasha Nikochevski, and others—across theaters from Normandy to the Pacific. Each mission feels like a vignette from a war film, whether storming a U-boat pen or sabotaging a Japanese carrier. Narrative cohesion is thin, but the game compensates with cinematic brevity: briefings and cutscenes evoke wartime urgency without overloading players with exposition.

Themes & Dialogue:
The game’s themes orbit sacrifice, ingenuity, and the moral ambiguity of covert warfare. Dialogue is sparse but functional, with voice acting leaning into archetypes (gruff commandos, snarling Nazis). The real storytelling emerges through gameplay: a successful mission feels like a heist pulled against impossible odds, while failure underscores the fragility of life in war.

Historical Homage:
Pyro wore its influences proudly. Missions riff on iconic films—The Bridge on the River Kwai, Where Eagles Dare—while integrating real-world events like the Battle of Cherbourg. This blend of fact and fiction immerses players in a romanticized yet visceral depiction of WWII.

---

Gameplay Mechanics & Systems

Core Loop:
The heart of Commandos 2 is its real-time tactics gameplay. Players control a squad of up to six commandos, each with unique abilities: the Sapper plants explosives, the Thief picks locks, and Whiskey the dog ferries items. Missions demand meticulous planning, as alarms or missteps can doom the team. Stealth is paramount—distract guards with cigarettes, hide bodies in lockers, or snipe foes from shadows.

Innovations & Flaws:
– Interactivity: Enter buildings, peek through windows, and manipulate environments (e.g., rigging chandeliers to crush enemies).
– Inventory System: A grid-based inventory forces tactical choices—carry extra ammo or a medkit?
– AI Quirks: Enemy patrols exhibit rudimentary awareness, but their cone-of-sight mechanics were groundbreaking for 2001.
– Difficulty Spike: The learning curve is brutal. Tutorials are inadequate, and controls—91 hotkeys on PC—daunt newcomers. Console ports suffered further from clunky UI adaptations.

Character Balance:
While the original six commandos received upgrades (e.g., the Driver gained traps), new additions like the Thief and Seductress felt undercooked. The Sniper’s limited utility and the Thief’s inability to kill enemies often relegated them to niche roles.

---

World-Building, Art & Sound

Visual Design:
Commandos 2’s isometric visuals are a triumph of 2D artistry. From the snow-blown cliffs of “White Death” to the sun-drenched beaches of Savo Island, each environment is dense with detail: flickering lamplights, rustling foliage, and crumbling ruins. The shift to 3D interiors, though occasionally clunky, added verticality and claustrophobic tension.

Atmosphere & Sound:
Mateo Pascual’s soundtrack oscillates between haunting dirges and pulse-pacing action themes, complemented by ambient sounds (howling winds, distant gunfire). Voice acting is hammy but endearing, though weak sound effects (tinny gunshots) occasionally undermine immersion.

Cinematic Flair:
Pre-rendered cutscenes, though dated by modern standards, lent a blockbuster sheen. The opening montage—real WWII footage intercut with in-game action—sets a tone of gritty grandeur.

---

Reception & Legacy

Launch Reception:
The PC version earned acclaim (83% average on MobyGames, 87 Metacritic) for its depth and challenge, though critics noted its punishing difficulty. Console ports fared worse, lambasted for clumsy controls. Commercial performance was solid (500k+ sold) but below expectations, contributing to Eidos’ financial woes at the time.

Enduring Influence:
Commandos 2 inspired successors like Shadow Tactics and Desperados III, which refined its stealth-strategy formula. The 2020 HD remaster modernized visuals but drew criticism for censoring Nazi iconography and failing to overhaul dated controls.

Cultural Impact:
The game remains a cult classic, celebrated for its ambition and unforgiving gameplay. It pioneered systems—body hiding, environmental interactivity—that became genre staples.

---

Conclusion

Commandos 2: Men of Courage is a time capsule of early-2000s ambition—a game unafraid to challenge players with complexity, dazzle them with artistry, and immerse them in a cinematic war epic. Its flaws—opaque controls, uneven difficulty—are relics of its era, yet they pale against its strengths: meticulously crafted missions, unparalleled atmosphere, and a depth that rewards patience. Two decades later, it stands as a testament to the power of tactical gameplay—a masterclass in tension, creativity, and the art of war.

Final Verdict: A cornerstone of the real-time tactics genre, Commandos 2 remains essential for strategy purists and WWII enthusiasts alike. Its legacy endures not just in HD remasters, but in the shadow it casts over every stealth game that followed.