Fellowship

Fellowship is a cooperative online dungeon-crawling RPG developed by Chief Rebel, blending survival, strategy, and RPG elements in a fantasy setting. Players team up to tackle progressively challenging dungeons, relying on skill, teamwork, and strategic decisions to uncover treasure and overcome obstacles. The game features a variety of heroes, weapons, and classes, with a focus on multiplayer cooperation and dynamic gameplay.

Fellowship: Review

Introduction

In the crowded landscape of multiplayer gaming, Fellowship emerges as a bold experiment—a “Multiplayer Online Dungeon Adventure” (MODA) designed to distill the cooperative thrill of MMO endgame dungeons into a streamlined, accessible package. Developed by Stockholm-based Chief Rebel—a studio founded by veterans of World of Warcraft, Diablo, and Helldivers—and published by Arc Games, this title promises to bypass the grind of traditional MMOs, delivering pure dungeon action from the first minute. Its core thesis is audacious: to create a genre that merges the tactical depth of MOBAs with the loot-driven progression of ARPGs, all wrapped in the cooperative spirit of MMOs. Yet, as a 2025 Early Access release, Fellowship stands as a compelling but flawed foundation, one that captures the essence of its inspirations while struggling with execution. This review examines how Fellowship navigates its ambitious vision, where it excels, and where its unfinished edges shape its place in gaming history.

---

Development History & Context

Chief Rebel’s genesis traces to 2018, when industry veterans—including alumni from Blizzard, DICE, and Ubisoft—sought to address a persistent gap in the market: the accessibility of high-level dungeon content. Their vision was born from two inspirations: the PvE potential of MOBAs and the endgame dungeons of MMOs like World of Warcraft. Frustrated by the barriers to entry in MMOs—grinding, story prerequisites, and time commitments—they envisioned a game where players could dive directly into the “holy trinity” gameplay of tanking, healing, and dealing damage without the baggage.

Technologically, Fellowship leverages Unreal Engine 5, opting for stylized graphics that prioritize performance and clarity over photorealism. This choice reflects both budget constraints and a deliberate nod to the vibrant, approachable aesthetics of titles like World of Warcraft. The gaming landscape at its October 2025 launch was fiercely competitive, with live-service games dominating. Chief Rebel positioned Fellowship as a niche alternative—stripped of open worlds and narrative, focusing solely on replayable dungeons. Its development cycle was marked by extensive playtesting, including a closed alpha in August 2024 and public betas during Steam Next Fest, ensuring community feedback shaped its progression systems. Arc Games, known for titles like Remnant II, provided publishing muscle, emphasizing a “premium” model ($24.99) with no subscriptions or pay-to-win mechanics.

---

Narrative & Thematic Deep Dive

Narrative takes a deliberate backseat in Fellowship, serving as scaffolding for its dungeon-first ethos. The game unfolds in a fantasy realm where players inhabit the “Stronghold,” a hub rebuilt atop ancient ruins, hinting at a world shaped by forgotten heroes. Dungeons—such as Empyrean Sands and Wraithtide Isles—are thematically distinct zones, each with implied lore (e.g., the Siren’s domain in Sailor’s Abyss suggests a history of maritime curses). Yet, explicit storytelling is minimal; dialogue exists primarily in the hub, with NPCs offering cryptic worldbuilding snippets rather than quests.

The narrative strength lies in its themes. Fellowship celebrates cooperation, with its title reflecting the bonds forged in adversity. Each hero embodies an archetype—Helena the stoic tank, Ardeos the pyromancer DPS, Sylvie the nature-based healer—designed to evoke classic RPG fantasies. Their interactions are subtle, conveyed through visual design and combat roles rather than dialogue. The game’s core message—that mastery comes through teamwork—is reinforced by mechanics like the “Kill Score,” which prevents skipping trash mobs, forcing players to engage with every challenge. This lack of overt story is intentional: it prioritizes gameplay-driven immersion, though it risks leaving players craving deeper lore.

---

Gameplay Mechanics & Systems

At its heart, Fellowship revolves around the “Holy Trinity”: Tank, Healer, and DPS. Players select from nine heroes at launch (e.g., the monk-like tank Meiko, the celestial archer Elarion), each with a unique kit of 15 abilities unlocked as difficulty increases. Combat uses a tab-targeting system reminiscent of World of Warcraft, emphasizing precise positioning and cooldown management. Abilities include hero-specific mechanics—like Elarion’s “Focus” resource or Mara’s combo-point-based assassinations—adding depth beyond generic rotations.

Core Loops and Progression:
– Dungeon Modes: Quickplay (10–15 minute runs, no gear rewards) and Challenge (progressive difficulty tiers with escalating mechanics and loot).
– Loot System: Gear drops post-dungeon, with one item per player. Upgrades use “Ingots” (scrap materials) to reroll stats or add sockets.
– Talent Trees: Hero-specific customization, with passives enhancing abilities (e.g., buffing Meiko’s combo finishers).
– Trinkets: Equippable utility items (portals, resurrection) that solve MMO-era class homogenization issues.

Innovations and Flaws:
The “Kill Score” mechanic is a standout, requiring players to clear 100% of enemies before bosses, preventing route-skipping and encouraging strategic pathing. Higher difficulties introduce “Curses”—modifiers like “Enemy Healing” or “Explosive Corpses”—that demand adaptability. However, systems feel unbalanced:
– Loot: Single-item drops and sparse gold rewards hinder progression, especially for casual players.
– Matchmaking: No mid-dungeon replacement for disconnected players forces wasted runs.
– Complexity: While accessible, the talent system lacks depth, and gear often feels stat-focused rather than transformative.

---

World-Building, Art & Sound

Fellowship’s world-building is minimalist yet evocative. Dungeons like Cithrel’s Ascent (a crystalline mine) and Urrak Markets (a bazaar of thieves) are visually distinct, with environmental storytelling through decayed architecture and enemy designs. The Stronghold hub—a bustling fortress—serves as a social anchor, with player avatars and emotes fostering camaraderie.

Art direction prioritizes clarity and functionality. Stylized character designs (e.g., Helena’s icy plate, Ardeos’ fiery robes) draw clear inspiration from World of Warcraft, while environments use color to guide players (e.g., lush greens in Everdawn Grove vs. desolate grays in Godfall Quarry). Although the Unreal Engine 5 backbone ensures technical polish, the visuals lack standout flair, occasionally resembling mobile-game aesthetics.

Sound design reinforces immersion. Combat impacts have satisfying weight, and dungeon-specific audio—like the echoing chants in Wraithtide Isles—enhances atmosphere. The Halloween event’s haunting music and eerie sound effects exemplify how environmental audio elevates mood. However, voice acting is limited, and tracks often loop excessively during long runs.

---

Reception & Legacy

Fellowship’s launch on October 16, 2025, was met with enthusiasm tempered by technical hiccups. Over 40,000 concurrent players flocked to its Steam page, praising its core loop and accessibility. Critics lauded its combat responsiveness and smart quality-of-life features (e.g., HUD customization, integrated damage meters). MMORPG.com noted it “captures the hearts of long-time MMO dungeon fans,” while This Week in Video Games commended its “addictive sense of mastery.”

Yet, reception was mixed. Rectify Gaming scored it 55%, calling it “enjoyable in short bursts” but criticizing visual blandness. Gameluster’s 30% review accused it of “impeding advancement,” citing punishing loot rates. Community feedback echoed these sentiments, with Steam forums demanding mid-dungeon matchmaking and richer gear rewards.

Legacy-wise, Fellowship pioneers the “MODA” genre, influencing titles like Overlord: Fellowship of Evil and The Fellowship of the Ring (1985). Its focus on cooperative endgame could reshape live-service design, proving that stripped-down, player-centric experiences thrive. However, its longevity hinges on post-launch updates—Chief Rebel has pledged seasonal events, new heroes, and raids. If it refines its systems and expands content, Fellowship could become a genre benchmark; otherwise, it risks fading as a niche curiosity.

---

Conclusion

Fellowship is a testament to the power of focused design. By distilling MMO dungeon crawling into its purest form, Chief Rebel has crafted an experience that feels both familiar and refreshingly accessible. Its combat, progression, and cooperative spirit are undeniably compelling, offering the satisfaction of overcoming challenges with friends. Yet, as an Early Access title, it remains a work in progress—flawed by a punitive loot system, minimal narrative, and rough edges in social features.

Verdict: Fellowship is a strong foundation for a new genre. It won’t revolutionize gaming, but it delivers exactly what it promises: dungeon runs without the grind. For fans of World of Warcraft’s Mythic+ or Diablo’s cooperative action, it’s a must-try—especially at its modest price. With continued polish and content updates, Fellowship could ascend from a promising experiment to a modern classic. For now, it stands as a heartfelt ode to the bonds forged in the heart of darkness, proving that fellowship—both in-game and out—is timeless.